Mark's Articles
9 - In your dreams (continued)
Icterine WarblerHippolais icterina Texel, Noord-Holland, Netherlands, 20 July 2011 (René Pop).
Icterine Warbler
The key characteristic of Icterine Warbler song that instantly separates it from anything else is its timbre. Icterine has a peculiar 'squeaky toy' timbre, due to a very rich presence of harmonics. This is most audible in the longer notes, but looking at sonagrams, more than half of the notes in the song show great piles of harmonics. Not even its closest relative Melodious Warbler has a similar degree of 'squeakiness'. There are other ways to separate the two species, which are described under Melodious, but timbre is a good place to start. Icterine may have a few whistled notes too that lack the squeaky toy timbre, typically associated with wild twists and turns of pitch, but far more of the song has it than lacks it.
Icterine Warbler song exists in two main structural variants, which may appear in the same bout of singing. In the commonest variant, the strophes are relatively short (mean 7 s, n = 8 individuals) and contain a succession of motifs, each one repeated several times, sometimes with slight variations in rhythm. A motif may consist of a single unit of sound, an imitation in most cases, or two combined into a rhythmic pattern. Sometimes a previous motif is interjected now and then between iterations of a new one. When Magnus analysed songs of 8 individuals he found that a new motif was introduced to the strophe on average once every 1.1 seconds. In those 8 individuals, the mean varied from 0.6 to 1.5 s. This is a rate of variation very similar to a Eurasian Reed Warbler, although Icterine's song seems far more varied to our ears, because the kinds of sounds used are much more contrasting. Usually there are longer series of repetitions in the first part of each strophe, and towards the end the new motifs appear in slightly quicker succession.
Icterine Warbler Hippolais icterina Hollandse Kade, Utrecht, Netherlands, 04:13, 2 June 2011 (Arnoud B van den Berg). Song with the usual short type of strophes. Note that this individual is singing a duel with another in the distance, and they challenge each other to match strophes. Background: Eurasian Skylark Alauda arvensis. 110602.AB.041300.01
This kind of Icterine Warbler song might be mistaken for a Marsh Warbler, but there are several ways to tell them apart. One is that there are no massive accelerations about 4 times a minute, characteristic of Marsh. Icterine has a relatively stable tempo, though not as steady and monotonous as a Reed Warbler. Secondly there is the squeaky timbre of Icterine. A third thing to listen for is Icterine's taste in mimicry: Eurasian Oystercatcher Haematopus ostralegus (pi-PEEP, pi-PEEP, pi-PEEP) and two smaller falcons, Common Kestrel Falco tinnunculus and Eurasian Hobby F subbuteo are particular favourites. Differences from Blyth's Reed Warbler include the squeaky timbre and the faster rate of change of the motifs, with new material typically appearing every second.
Icterine Warbler Hippolais icterina Schiermonnikoog, Groningen, Netherlands, 8 May 2003 (Magnus Robb). Song of a newly arrived male, with imitations including Western Jackdaw Corvus monedula (0:01-0:02), Eurasian Oystercatcher Haematopus ostralegus (0:02-0:03), Common Kestrel Falco tinnunculus (0:03-0:04, 0:14-0:16) and Red-backed Shrike Lanius collurio (0:49-0:50). 03.014.MR.11622.01
In the other, longer type of Icterine Warbler songs, repeating 'broken record' chunks may also be embedded, though nearly so often as in Blyth's Reed Warbler and Melodious Warbler. Longer Icterine songs may be anything from 15 seconds to well over a minute long, and for much of their duration they are structured in a similar way to the shorter strophes. The 'broken record'-style chunks, when they occur, may be up to 2.5 seconds long, and repeated either exactly or inexactly up to five or six times. In this way they can add considerably to the length of the strophe. While it is far from true that every long strophe has this feature, it is so striking when it occurs that the listener may be taken by surprise, and it is worth mentioning here. This is a feature shared with the other three members of the genus Hippolais, especially Upcher's Warbler H languida, which takes it to extremes.
Icterine Warbler Hippolais icterina Hollandse Kade, Utrecht, Netherlands, 04:13, 2 June 2011 (Arnoud B van den Berg). Song with the long type of strophes repeating several 'broken record chunks'. Background: Eurasian Coot Fulica atra and Eurasian Skylark Alauda arvensis. 110602.AB.041300.01
Icterine Warbler is rightly considered one of the top mimics in the Western Palearctic, and its Dutch name Spotvogel translates as 'mockingbird'. The imitations are often long enough to recognise, and back in 1979, Dowsett-Lemaire noted that the species imitated are basically European, finding no mimicry of African birds at all. Given her vast knowledge of African songs and calls, it would be natural to take her word as gospel. However, we have found at least one instance of an African bird being imitated. Magnus learned the sound of White-throated Bee-eater M albicollis, funnily enough, from a Common Redstart Phoenicurus phoenicurus in Germany while trying to recognise as many imitations as possible in its song. Then in 2019 he had the opportunity to record this bee-eater in Ghana. Its calls are very distinctive, so we can be fairly confident that when we recognise them in an Icterine Warbler song this is no chance resemblance. The Icterine in question was recorded by Arnoud in Holland, and the White-throated Bee-eater is basically a Sahel species, spending the non-breeding season in the rainforest. Our Icterine may have heard it on its journey to southern Africa in our autumn, or the return journey in our spring. With recent WP records in Western Sahara and Israel, this bee-eater's calls are well worth memorising.
White-throated Bee-eater Merops albicollis Mole National Park, Savannah Region, Ghana, 09:30, 11 November 2019 (Magnus Robb). Calls from a flock perched in a tree. 191111.MR.093052.21